Stock Portfolio Rebalancing After Divorce: Avoiding Wash-Sale Rules
A divorce decree marks the legal end of a marriage, but it is the beginning of a new, separate financial life. The division of assets, painstakingly negotiated or court-ordered, leaves each individual with a collection of assets. When those assets include a significant investment portfolio, the work is far from over.
How Are Financial Assets Divided in a West Virginia Divorce?
To see the problem clearly, it helps to review how assets are divided. West Virginia is an “equitable distribution” state. This does not mean a 50/50 split. It means the court will divide marital property in a way it deems fair.
The process generally follows these steps:
- Identification: All assets and debts owned by the couple are identified.
- Classification: Each asset is classified as either “separate property” (owned before the marriage, an inheritance, a gift) or “marital property” (acquired during the marriage).
- Valuation: Marital assets, including investment accounts, are valued. This can be complex, often requiring a specific valuation date set by the court.
- Distribution: The court divides the marital property.
An investment account, even if it is in one spouse’s name, is typically marital property if the funds were contributed or grew during the marriage. The divorce decree will order that a portion of these assets be transferred to the other spouse.
What Does “Transfer Incident to Divorce” Mean for My Stocks?
This is the first critical financial concept to grasp. When your spouse transfers stocks, bonds, or mutual funds to you as part of a divorce settlement, the IRS does not view this as a sale. It is a “transfer incident to divorce,” governed by IRC Section 1041.
This has two massive implications:
- No Tax on the Transfer: Your spouse does not pay capital gains tax on the transfer, and you do not pay any tax to receive the assets.
- You Inherit the Cost Basis: This is the important part. You receive the stocks with the exact same cost basis as your spouse had.
Let’s use an example. Your spouse bought 1,000 shares of Company XYZ ten years ago for $10,000 (a cost basis of $10 per share). Today, those shares are worth $100,000. As part of the divorce, those 1,000 shares are transferred to you. You pay no tax now. However, your cost basis is still $10,000. If you immediately sell all the shares for $100,000, you have a $90,000 capital gain and will be responsible for the entire tax bill.
Distinguishing Brokerage Accounts from Retirement Accounts (QDROs)
It is important to separate two different types of financial accounts. The rules discussed here primarily apply to standard, taxable brokerage accounts.
- Taxable Brokerage Accounts: These are investment accounts funded with post-tax dollars. Transfers are handled by the divorce decree and Section 1041, as described above.
- Retirement Accounts: These include 401(k)s, 403(b)s, and some pensions. These are tax-advantaged accounts. Dividing them requires a specific court order called a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO). A QDRO allows the funds to be moved from one spouse’s retirement plan to the other’s (often into a rollover IRA) without incurring taxes or penalties at the time of the transfer.
The wash sale rule applies to your taxable brokerage accounts, not typically to trades made within a tax-deferred IRA or 401(k).
Why Must I Rebalance My Portfolio After a Divorce?
The portfolio you receive from a divorce is rarely one you would build for yourself. It is the result of a legal division, not a financial strategy. Rebalancing—selling certain assets and buying others—is necessary for several reasons:
- New Risk Tolerance: Your financial goals and willingness to accept market risk as a single individual are almost certainly different from when you were part of a couple.
- Over-Concentration: The division may leave you with a dangerously high percentage of one company’s stock (perhaps your ex-spouse’s employer).
- New Financial Goals: Your timeline for retirement, plans to buy a new home, or need for income are now yours alone.
- Liquidity Needs: You may simply need to sell assets to generate cash for a down payment, pay off marital debt, or cover living expenses.
- Inherited “Losers”: The portfolio may contain assets that have performed poorly, and you may wish to sell them to offset gains from other sales. This is where the trouble starts.
The Goal: Tax-Loss Harvesting
When you start rebalancing, you will likely sell some assets that have gains (like the Company XYZ example) and some that have losses. A common financial strategy is “tax-loss harvesting.”
This is the practice of selling a security that is at a loss to “harvest” that loss. You can then use that capital loss on your tax return to offset capital gains you may have realized from selling “winner” stocks. If your losses exceed your gains, you can even deduct a portion against your ordinary income.
This is a sound strategy, but it has one major roadblock: the Wash Sale Rule.
What Is the Wash Sale Rule and How Does It Complicate Rebalancing?
The Wash Sale Rule is an IRS regulation designed to prevent investors from “cheating” the system. It stops you from selling a stock to claim the tax loss, only to immediately buy it back because you still think it’s a good investment.
The Rule: The wash sale rule states that you cannot claim a capital loss from selling a security if you buy a “substantially identical” security within 30 days before or 30 days after the sale.
This creates a 61-day window (30 days before, the day of sale, and 30 days after).
Example:
- You own 100 shares of Stock A, which you bought for $50 per share.
- It is now trading at $40 per share. You sell it for a $1,000 loss.
- You want to claim that $1,000 loss on your taxes.
- But, 10 days later, you decide you “sold too soon” and buy 100 shares of Stock A back.
- Result: The wash sale rule is triggered. You cannot claim the $1,000 loss. Instead, the loss is disallowed, and its amount is added to the cost basis of your new purchase.
How Does the Wash Sale Rule Create a Trap After Divorce?
The wash sale rule becomes a nightmare during a post-divorce rebalance. The “you” in the rule can be more complicated than you think, especially in the year the divorce is finalized.
Here are the common traps:
The Individual Rebalancing Trap: This is the simplest. You get your portfolio. You sell losing Stock B to harvest the loss. You then buy an ETF (Exchange Traded Fund) that tracks the technology sector, but Stock B is a major component of that ETF. The IRS could argue this is “substantially identical” and disallow your loss.
The “Joint Filer” Trap: Many couples file taxes “married filing jointly” for the final year of their marriage. In this situation, the IRS views “you” as the joint entity.
- Scenario: You receive your half of the brokerage account. Your ex-spouse receives theirs.
- You sell 100 shares of Stock C at a loss.
- Within 30 days, your ex-spouse, using their separate account, buys 100 shares of Stock C (perhaps thinking it’s a good deal).
- Because you are filing a joint return, the IRS sees that “you” (the joint couple) sold and repurchased the stock within 30 days. Your loss is disallowed.
The “Spouse’s IRA” Trap: The IRS has made it clear that the rule also applies across different account types.
- Scenario: You sell Stock D at a loss in your taxable brokerage account.
- Within 30 days, you (or your ex-spouse, if filing jointly) buy Stock D in an IRA or other retirement account.
- Result: The wash sale is triggered. The loss in your taxable account is disallowed permanently. You do not even get to add it to the cost basis in the IRA. The loss simply vanishes.
What Are “Substantially Identical” Securities?
This is a gray area where many people get into trouble. The IRS has not provided a perfect definition, but here is what is generally accepted:
Clearly Identical:
- The same stock (e.g., selling Apple and buying Apple).
- Options or contracts to buy the same stock.
- Stock of the same company (e.g., Class A vs. Class B shares).
Clearly NOT Identical:
- Stock in two different companies in the same industry (e.g., selling Ford and buying General Motors).
- An S&P 500 index fund and a small-cap index fund.
The Dangerous Gray Area:
- Two different S&P 500 index funds from different providers (e.g., selling Vanguard’s S&P 500 and buying Fidelity’s S&P 500). These track the same index and are very likely “substantially identical.”
- Selling a specific company’s stock and buying a very narrow sector ETF where that stock is the primary holding.
Strategies to Avoid Wash Sale Complications During a Divorce Rebalance
Given these complex rules, your post-divorce rebalancing must be done with care and precision. A deliberate plan is essential.
Strategy 1: Wait 31 Days
- The simplest solution. If you sell a security for a loss, wait 31 full days before buying it or anything “substantially identical” back. Put a note on your calendar.
Strategy 2: Coordinate with Your Ex-Spouse
- If you plan to file jointly for the final tax year, communication is paramount. You and your ex-spouse (or your financial teams) must agree not to repurchase any security that the other spouse sells for a loss. This can be formalized in the divorce agreement.
Strategy 3: Sell for Gains First
- The wash sale rule only applies to losses. You can sell winning stocks and buy them back the next day if you want (though there is rarely a reason to). Prioritize your sales. You may have significant gains from low-basis stock (from Section 3) that can be offset by losses.
Strategy 4: Buy the Replacement First
- If you want to sell Stock A (at a loss) and buy Stock B (a similar competitor), consider buying Stock B first. Hold both for 31 days. Then sell Stock A. This “doubles up” your exposure for a month, but it completely avoids the wash sale window.
Strategy 5: Use Different Asset Classes
- When you sell a losing stock, replace it with something clearly different. If you sell a large-cap U.S. stock, use the proceeds to buy a small-cap fund, an international fund, or a bond fund. This also helps with diversification.
Contact Pence Law Firm for Knowledgeable Guidance
Divorce is more than a legal process; it is a financial restructuring. If you are in West Virginia and facing a divorce involving a complex portfolio, stock options, or other investments, you need a legal team that sees the full picture. The attorneys at the Pence Law Firm are committed to helping you navigate every aspect of your case, from the legal filings in family court to the complex financial implications of your settlement. We prepare every case thoroughly, ready to protect your financial future.
We invite you to contact us online or call our office at 304-345-7250 to schedule a confidential consultation to discuss your case.

